The Moment
Cynthia Erivo is done pretending everything is fine.
In her new hybrid memoir and self-help book, Simply More: A Book for Anyone Who’s Been Told They’re Simply Too Much, the 38-year-old Tony winner writes about being abandoned by her father at 16, left alone in a London Underground station after an argument about a transit pass. She says they haven’t spoken since.
The Wicked and Genius: Aretha star also opens up about how her queerness has strained parts of her family life, sharing that her mother is still working to reconcile the daughter she imagined with the woman Erivo has become, and that it took her sister even longer to accept her sexuality.
And then there’s the story that’s built to light up group chats: years ago, during a rehearsal at Los Angeles’ Greek Theatre, Erivo describes having a “blackout” rage at her then-manager after he brought a crowd of friends to watch without warning. Friends had to defuse the confrontation; the manager quit via email afterward, scolding her as he left.
It’s raw, it’s messy, and it’s very much Erivo drawing a line between the polished red-carpet image and the complicated human underneath.
The Take
I’ll be honest: the “blackout rage” anecdote is going to get the loudest headlines, because nothing revs up the internet like a woman – especially a Black woman – admitting she lost her temper.
But the real story here isn’t one angry outburst; it’s a lifetime of being told she’s “too much” and finally deciding she’d rather be too much than not herself at all.
On paper, Erivo has the kind of resume that looks bulletproof: a Tony, an Emmy, a Grammy, two Oscar nominations, and now she’s literally playing the misunderstood green girl in the Wicked films. Yet in her own life, she grew up in a home where queerness wasn’t discussed, where coming into her identity meant risking the love and approval of the people closest to her.
That tension – between being celebrated publicly and questioned privately – is the real heartbreak. She describes treading carefully around her family, noting that her mother worries what people will think and is still “working to reconcile” her expectations with reality. Her sister, she says, took even longer to come around, though they’re finally getting over “a bit of a hump” and finding their way back to each other.
Put that next to a father who walked out when she was a teenager and never looked back, and of course there are scars. Of course there’s anger. If you grow up with abandonment and conditional acceptance, your emotional wiring is going to be… complicated.
Is screaming at a manager in front of other people a good look? No. And to her credit, Erivo doesn’t spin it as heroic. She admits she scared herself, that she “utterly blacked out with rage.” She owns that it was too much, even for her.
What I actually find healthy – and a little radical – is that she’s not hiding the ugly parts in order to stay brand-safe. Celebrities are usually taught to turn their trauma into neat TED Talk sound bites. Erivo is giving us something messier: a woman who can be brilliant, loving, and still occasionally detonated by her own pain.
If anything, this feels less like a scandal and more like a reckoning with what it costs to live authentically when your authentic self doesn’t match your family’s script. It’s Elphaba all over again: punished for being different, told to shrink, and finally deciding to defy gravity anyway.
Receipts
- Confirmed: In Simply More (Flatiron Books, out now), Erivo writes that her father left her in a London Tube station when she was 16 and that they have not spoken since.
- Confirmed: In the book, she describes having a furious outburst at a former manager at the Greek Theatre in Los Angeles after he brought uninvited friends to watch her rehearsal, saying she “blacked out with rage” and that he later resigned by email.
- Confirmed: Erivo writes that her mother has struggled with her queerness and worries about “what others think,” and that her sister took longer than her mother to accept Erivo’s sexuality, though their relationship is improving.
- Confirmed: Erivo publicly came out as bisexual in a 2022 interview with British Vogue, saying LGBTQ+ people still feel pressure to justify why they deserve equal treatment.
- Reported: Coverage of the new book notes that Erivo has been in a relationship with actress and producer Lena Waithe since 2022.
- Unverified: The exact current state of Erivo’s relationships with her parents and extended family beyond what she shares in the memoir.
Backstory (For Casual Readers)
If Cynthia Erivo’s name rings a bell but you can’t quite place it, here’s the refresher. She first broke out on Broadway, winning a Tony Award for her powerhouse performance as Celie in The Color Purple. Hollywood came calling fast: she earned two Oscar nominations in 2020 for playing Harriet Tubman in Harriet – one for Best Actress and one for co-writing the original song “Stand Up.”
Since then, she’s starred in TV projects like Genius: Aretha and is now headlining as Elphaba in the big-budget Wicked movies. In 2022, she publicly embraced the label bisexual, after years of dating men and later beginning a relationship with Lena Waithe, the Emmy-winning creator of Master of None and The Chi.
In other words, this is not some overnight fame situation. Erivo has been climbing for years – and now that she’s at a peak, she’s turning around and showing us the mountain she had to drag herself up.
What’s Next
Books like this don’t just drop and disappear. Expect more headlines as additional stories from Simply More surface, especially around her family dynamics and how she navigated coming out while building a career in a very straight-acting industry.
With the Wicked films rolling out and Erivo front and center on a massive franchise, her personal narrative is going to travel right alongside the green makeup and high notes. I wouldn’t be surprised to see in-depth sit-down interviews where she expands on the fallout with her father, how things stand with her mom and sister now, and what she’s learned about anger and boundaries since that Greek Theatre incident.
For fans, the bigger question might be what being “too much” looks like going forward. Does she get more outspoken, more protective of her space, more open about the messy parts? Or does she decide that telling this story once, on her own terms, is enough?
Either way, she’s made one thing very clear: being palatable to everyone – family, fans, or former managers – is no longer the goal.
What about you? When a celebrity shares the hard, unflattering parts of their story like this, does it make you trust them more, or do you prefer some of that mystery to stay intact?
Comments