The Moment
Mandy Moore is not hiding in a pantry scrolling comments like the rest of us would. Instead, she spent Saturday night onstage at The Wiltern in Los Angeles, reunited with her former This Is Us co-stars Sterling K. Brown and Chris Sullivan for a live taping of their This Was Us podcast.
According to a Jan. 19, 2026 celebrity news report, Moore didn’t just sit and reminisce about Pearson family trauma; she also sang onstage, backed by her husband, musician Taylor Goldsmith, while fans filmed and posted the moment on social media.
Mandy Moore reunites with ‘This Is Us’ co-stars in first public outing since ‘toxic’ mom group drama https://t.co/7yRpirMsOS pic.twitter.com/cHzpzM1RMz
— Page Six (@PageSix) January 19, 2026
This is Moore’s first big public outing since she was allegedly part of the now-infamous “toxic” celebrity mom group that Ashley Tisdale wrote about in a viral personal essay earlier this month. That essay claimed the group included a handful of famous moms – reportedly names like Hilary Duff and Meghan Trainor – and centered on Tisdale feeling iced out of hangs and left off certain group texts.
In the piece, Tisdale described realizing there were side text chains, seeing photos of gatherings she wasn’t invited to, and finally asking herself why she kept “showing up” for a friendship circle that made her feel small. After publication, several women believed to be in the group – and at least one husband – seemed to push back on social media, mocking or minimizing the essay without naming Tisdale outright.
Moore, for her part, hasn’t gone scorched-earth. Instead, she’s offered carefully worded reflections. On the Conversations with Cam podcast, she talked about how friendships can “take a different course” when you’re in different seasons of parenting, and admitted she’s had to “mourn” how some friendships have changed, even when the kids are the same age.
The Take
I’m just going to say it: this entire saga is giving high school cafeteria with better lighting and a Pilates budget.
Strip away the celebrity gloss and what you have is a classic mom-group dynamic: one person feels excluded, others insist everything is fine, and the truth probably lives somewhere between “mean girls” and “messy, imperfect humans who didn’t handle it well.”
What’s fascinating is how differently the key players are handling the fallout. Tisdale chose the long, emotional essay – essentially publishing a breakup letter to her friend group. Some of the alleged members (and their spouses) chose sarcasm on Instagram, which always reads a little defensive, like, “I’m fine, this is fine, I’m absolutely not mad at all.”
Moore’s lane so far? The soft-focus route. She shows up for a nostalgic night with her beloved TV family, shares the stage with her husband, and when she does address the situation, she talks about “chapters” and “mourning” friendships instead of calling anyone out by name.
It’s a savvy move. By leaning into work – a live podcast tied to a show people genuinely loved – she reminds everyone why we cared about her long before this mom-group drama. And by framing friendship shifts as a normal part of parenting life, she signals, very gently, that whatever happened, she’s not going to litigate it in public.
The whole thing feels like watching two versions of adulthood collide: the one where you blast your feelings to an audience, and the one where you process them in coded language and keep it moving. Neither is inherently wrong, but one does keep your career and reputation a lot cleaner.
If the mom group was the messy group chat, Saturday night at The Wiltern was Moore hitting “mute” and walking out into an actual room full of people who were just happy to see her sing.
Receipts
Confirmed:
- Mandy Moore appeared at The Wiltern in Los Angeles on Saturday for a live taping related to This Is Us, alongside Sterling K. Brown and Chris Sullivan, and performed onstage with her husband Taylor Goldsmith, as described in a Jan. 19, 2026 celebrity news report and fan social media posts.
- Ashley Tisdale published a first-person essay in early January 2026 describing a “toxic” mom group of celebrity friends and detailing feeling excluded from certain hangouts and group text chains.
- In that essay, Tisdale wrote that she saw social media photos of gatherings she was not invited to and eventually questioned why she continued to participate in the group.
- Moore discussed changing friendships and parenting stages on the Conversations with Cam podcast, saying she has had to “mourn” how certain friendships have changed, even when kids are the same age.
Unverified / Alleged:
- That Mandy Moore was definitively a member of the exact mom group Tisdale wrote about; Moore has not publicly confirmed her role, and Tisdale did not list every name in the essay.
- That specific women like Hilary Duff and Meghan Trainor were the primary targets of the essay; online speculation links them based on context and past photos, but that connection is inferred, not directly stated.
- That any of the women (or their husbands) intended direct shade with their social media posts; intent can’t be confirmed without their explicit statements.
Backstory (For Casual Readers)
If you dipped out of pop culture somewhere between dial-up and TikTok, a quick refresher: Mandy Moore started as a teen pop star (“Candy,” anyone?) and successfully reinvented herself as a respected actress, most recently as matriarch Rebecca Pearson on the NBC hit This Is Us. Ashley Tisdale rose to fame on Disney projects like The Suite Life of Zack & Cody and the High School Musical films. Hilary Duff is another former teen star turned working mom, and Meghan Trainor is a pop singer known for “All About That Bass.”
Over the past few years, social media has turned celebrity mom friendships into a kind of spectator sport. We get coordinated birthday trips, matching robes by the pool, cute kid playdates – all highly curated and heavily photographed. That glossy version makes it easy to forget that under the hats and handbags, these are still human relationships that can be cliquey, lopsided, and sometimes quietly cruel.
So when Tisdale pulled back the curtain on the “toxic” side of a glamorous mom group, it hit a nerve far beyond Hollywood. Suddenly, every woman who has ever watched the carpool clique walk past her at pickup had a celebrity-level mirror held up to her experience.
What’s Next
In the very near term, it looks like Mandy Moore is choosing to let her work – and her carefully worded podcast comments – speak louder than any Notes-app essay. If she keeps appearing at events with her This Is Us family and focusing on music with Taylor Goldsmith, the narrative may quietly shift back to her projects instead of her group chats.
For Ashley Tisdale, the question is whether she’ll double down and name names more clearly, or let the essay stand as her final word. If she does further interviews, how much detail she offers – and how directly other women are identified – will determine how long this stays a niche mom-war versus a full-on celebrity feud.
As for the broader “toxic mom group” conversation, don’t be surprised if more celebrities start talking about friendship breakups, boundary-setting, and what happens when your social life is also your brand. There’s a lot of pressure on famous moms to present a united, aspirational front; this situation pokes a big, messy hole in that.
For now, though, the most telling move might be the quietest one: Moore standing under the lights at The Wiltern, singing with her husband, while the mom drama plays out somewhere far less glamorous – in the comments, and in the group chats we’ll never see.
Sources: A celebrity news report published Jan. 19, 2026 describing Mandy Moore’s Wiltern appearance; Ashley Tisdale’s first-person essay on a digital magazine in early Jan. 2026; Mandy Moore’s remarks on the Conversations with Cam podcast, Jan. 2026.
What do you think: if you were in Mandy Moore’s position, would you address the mom-group drama directly, or keep it vague and focus on your work the way she seems to be doing?
Comments